How Investors Are Buying Into Preferred Equity To Lower Risk and Raise Returns

On this article

Did you catch the “Woodstock for Capitalists” occasion this 12 months? I’m speaking in regards to the Berkshire Hathaway annual assembly in Omaha. I tuned in for the entire occasion. With Warren Buffett aged 93 and Charlie Munger approaching 100, any 12 months could possibly be the final 12 months. 

What Munger stated about business actual property was troubling—however not stunning. 

Munger had beforehand warned of a brewing storm within the U.S. business property market, with American banks filled with unhealthy loans as property costs fall. At that assembly, he reiterated his concern, and Buffett strengthened it. 

For years, throughout actual property’s rising tide, traders clambered for larger and better returns. They requested, “How a lot can I make?”  

However the pattern all the time reverses in time. Now traders are asking, “How a lot may I lose?”

It’s occasions like this when traders cease discussing returns and revert to discussing risk-adjusted returns.  

Calling All Recovering Speculators

I’m a recovered speculator. Just a few a long time in the past, I targeted solely on returns and ignored the dangers. Now, my agency is obsessive about risk-adjusted returns, which is actually an altogether completely different metric. 

Whereas risk-adjusted returns have all the time been the main focus for excellent traders, there are specific seasons when uncommon alternatives floor—offers that don’t current themselves when money and income are flowing like inexperienced Chicago rivers on St. Patrick’s Day. 

We’re in a type of uncommon moments proper now. 

Most well-liked fairness offers quite a few advantages, together with larger security from a better place within the capital stack, fast money circulation, administration rights in case of delinquency, and a standard fairness cushion behind traders in first loss place as a defend in opposition to lowering asset values. 

To be clear, this isn’t the “most well-liked return” traders obtain as a part of their payout construction from syndicators. That’s nice, however that’s not what I’m speaking about. 

These alternatives are fairly completely different from the everyday most well-liked fairness gives you may need seen from multifamily and different sponsors as a part of their choices. Lots of these provide traders a debt-like money circulation stream (for instance, 8% to 10%) with little or no upside. 

Traders settle for decrease potential returns for money circulation and a safer place within the capital stack. We predict these are nice and that this can be a good time to take a look at these choices. However I’m speaking about one thing completely different. 

Particulars of the Offers

I made a robust case for most well-liked fairness in an earlier article. In one other, I defined my reasoning for why this can be a restricted window for most well-liked fairness offers. Some have requested for extra particulars on a few of the offers we’ve been evaluating. 

I don’t have room to elucidate all of them right here, however I’ll let you know about a chance we just lately evaluated the place threat and upside potential are seemingly misaligned—in favor of traders. 

This deal nonetheless helped an operator efficiently execute an acquisition. 

We’re evaluating fairly a couple of most well-liked fairness alternatives with traits like this one. Listed here are some particulars:

Worth-add multifamily acquisition, with an skilled sponsor subsequent door to one in every of their present profitable tasks. 
25% frequent fairness in first-loss place as a defend behind most well-liked fairness traders.
Present pay money circulation of 9% reserved upfront for one 12 months, plus accrued upside of 8% compounded. 
MOIC (a number of on invested capital) flooring of 1.30x, which offers a 30% minimal complete return, with a projected exit in 18 months (as much as a 20% annual return if this performs out).   
Money circulation sweep and administration management rights (together with the correct to drive a sale) to guard traders in case of bother.  

In the event you put money into a deal like this, you wouldn’t signal a boilerplate settlement like every of us would do as particular person traders. You’d wish to rent an skilled legal professional to craft paperwork with provisions to guard you and to offer rights that no particular person investor would obtain (if they might get entry).  

The chance mentioned right here is one in every of many. The full return of 17% (with the potential to obtain a better return if the MOIC flooring is triggered in 18 months) is extra enticing than many frequent fairness alternatives. 

However the threat is theoretically a lot decrease because of capital stack place, precedence of distributions from money circulation (together with money circulation seep), present pay reserve, and supervisor removing rights. 

This funding aligns with many BP traders’ first precedence of capital preservation, a second precedence of predictable revenue, and a 3rd precedence of fairness appreciation. And this one passes by means of tax advantages from depreciation besides.  

To be clear, I’m not suggesting traders abandon particular person LP investments. We consider in broad diversification, and most well-liked fairness could be a part of an awesome portfolio. 

Lately, I discussed one in every of our most subtle traders who helped me make clear what a uncommon and brief window of alternative is offered to make investments like these. 

I forgot to say that he chided me a bit once I was explaining our rationale for investing in most well-liked fairness. However his light rebuke was not about investing in most well-liked fairness. He chided me for not investing extra in pref fairness—particularly on this uncommon and slim window of time. 

He sees the chance. We see the chance. And we hope lots of you do, too.

Observe By BiggerPockets: These are opinions written by the creator and don’t essentially signify the opinions of BiggerPockets.